Photo credit Amir Arefi
NY’s “brownfields”
toxic chemicals still poison soil and groundwater decades after closure
New York’s “brownfields” are the scars of its industrial past. Abandoned factories, gas stations, tanneries, and mills where toxic chemicals still poison soil and groundwater decades after closure. The state’s Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP) was meant to transform these sites into safe, usable land. But a recent audit by the New York State Comptroller found that many projects, especially in the Capital Region, have been languishing for years, leaving residents to live beside invisible dangers that government oversight has failed to resolve.
Visit the InformedNY Round Table
for discussions on Poison Soils and Toxic Chemicals
https://www.facebook.com/groups/informednyroundtable
#HealthINY #FollowTheMoneyINY #EnvironmentINY- #LegislationINY –
[restrict userlevel="subscriber"]
The brownfield program relies on a voluntary system: property owners or developers apply, clean up contamination under DEC supervision, and receive tax credits for redevelopment. It sounds like a win-win, but it breaks down when owners run out of money, change hands, or simply stall. The audit revealed dozens of sites that have sat in limbo for a decade or more, some with cleanup plans that were never finished, others with new contamination discovered after incomplete remediation. Among the worst are the former Troy Belting & Supply site in Colonie, where solvents remain trapped under factory floors; the Stevens & Thompson Paper Mill in Greenwich, tied up in litigation; and Victory Mills near Schuylerville, whose ruins recently caught fire, spreading ash over nearby homes.
This is not paperwork delay. These are properties laced with industrial solvents, petroleum hydrocarbons, and heavy metals that leach into soil and water or rise as chemical vapors through cracks in basements. Exposure is linked to cancers, neurological issues, and developmental harm in children. New York’s Department of Health has warned for years that soil-vapor intrusion, the seepage of toxic fumes into homes, can occur miles from the original contamination. Yet the DEC’s own records show that many “managed” sites have monitoring plans that are out of date or missing data entirely.
Why have they languished? The program’s voluntary design gives DEC limited leverage: participants can withdraw, delay, or declare partial completion while retaining tax credits. The Comptroller’s report found cases where ownership changed and the agency was never notified, where developers concealed information, and where DEC’s internal database failed to flag sites eligible for the stricter State Superfund program. In other words, the system rewards participation, not results.
The risk is not just environmental; it’s moral. Many of these forgotten parcels sit in working-class or minority neighborhoods, where residents have little political voice. They see the fences and warning signs, breathe the air, and wonder whether their children are safe. These are the same communities told they’ll benefit from “redevelopment,” yet they watch investors collect credits while the contamination remains under their feet.
New York can fix this but only by replacing complacency with accountability. The state should impose firm cleanup deadlines and revoke incentives when they’re missed. Sites that stall must be transferred to the Superfund list, where the state can enforce timelines and penalties. DEC should create a public online “scoreboard” showing each brownfield’s age, contamination type, last inspection, and next required action. And most urgently, residents deserve plain-language reports on soil-vapor and groundwater tests for every site older than five years.
A century ago, upstate New York’s factories built the state’s wealth; their toxic leftovers should not be allowed to destroy its health. Every year a brownfield sits idle, the contamination spreads, property values erode, and communities lose faith in the promise that government will protect them. The time for quiet reports and unanswered audits is over. The people who live beside these sites have waited long enough.
[/restrict]
Staff Picks
Pseudo-Science is killing our enviroment
Photo by: Harisankar Those Who Claim to...
NYS shift away from Natural gas
New York’s Shift from Natural Gas: A Case for a...
Syracuse, a $16 million budget shortfall
Photo by John Marino from Pittsburgh -...